Tuesday, 6 October 2026

Stories from the Kitchen: A Vintage Macaroni Cheese Recipe

My Grandma, Sylvia, attended Catering College when she had left school and was 15, under the tutelage of Mr. Druce in the 1st year and Mr. Fanari in the 2nd. It was here that she learnt how to make a white roux sauce without getting lumps in it; she prided herself on being the only one in her group who was able to make said sauce without any lump! She tells me that if you don't get it 'right to start', then you will never be able to get the lumps out. We recently discussed the care and precision she took with her foray in domestic science, something she firmed up with training in silver service, and nanny work. Back to her exemplary white sauce, this got me thinking about the macaroni cheese she used to make in her early-twenties: a staple for the working girl with not much time on her hands. Seeing as I recently managed to make the best macaroni cheese of my life, I thought I'd share that recipe, along with some tidbits from Sylvia's post-graduate days in the city of Oxford.


Just before her 21st birthday, my Grandma was working for the blood transfusion and living in Oxford, down Walton Street, a thoroughfare running through the now rather trendy area of Jericho. This was her first time living away from her parent's house in Abingdon, and she was doing so in style, sharing a flat with two of her girl friends, Sally and Valerie. Theirs was a top floor flat, where she washed her clothes in the sink, and went to bed with an old discharged RAF overcoat supplied by the hospital and a dressing gown atop the covers due to the cold. 

During this era, she cooked up copious amounts of macaroni and cheese in the tiny kitchen, on the stove top of the gas hob. This gas hob was somewhat notorious: the gas for the flat frequently ran out and she would have to keep on feeding the meter with any coins that were ton hand! Practicalities aside, Grandma managed to make one of her favourite dishes often and from scratch, to a method that doesn't really require a recipe. She'd cook her macaroni, then make the aforementioned white sauce, to which she'd add a good amount of grated cheese. Then, she'd pour the sauce over the macaroni, dish it straight up into a bowl, and usually eat it standing. 

This was in the early-60s, right at the very start of the decade, when her schedule was rather ad-hoc with the blood transfusion. She started work at different hours of the day, so macaroni cheese was one of the dishes she'd make on her day off, or, if she was starting work in the afternoon, would have for lunch at the flat.


This brings me neatly to my own macaroni cheese, a homage to my Grandma Sylvia, to whom I owe a great deal and with whom I share a great many tastes and capabilities! To make this, improvisation and adaptations are much encouraged to accommodate your personal preferences. I tend to cook from instinct/by eye, so I've tried to be as helpful with the instructions as I possibly can, but there's room to deviate should you so desire! For the serving pictured, I'd added some leftover good-quality honey roast ham from a picnic, which may have tipped that version into the sublime. We all devoured our plates and there was enough for lunches the following day and to put a generous portion into the freezer, which could then be topped with cheese and baked at a later date. Without further ado, here are the particulars: 

Vintage Macaroni Cheese Recipe


Serves: 6–8
Oven: 190°C / 170°C fan / 375°F

Ingredients

  • 500g (17½ oz) grated mild or mature Cheddar (use your own preference) 
  • A handful or so of grated  mozzarella 
  • 500g (1 lb 2 oz) dried macaroni
  • 100g (3½ oz) salted butter
  • 100g (3½ oz) plain flour
  • 1 litre (1¾ pints / 4¼ cups) milk
  • Salt, black pepper and ground nutmeg to taste
  • Optional: a pinch of nutmeg

Method

  1. Cook the macaroni by bringing a large saucepan of salted water to the boil. Cook the macaroni for 1–2 minutes less than the packet instructions so it remains slightly firm. Drain well.
  2. Make the cheese sauce by melt the butter in a large saucepan over a medium heat. Add the flour and stir constantly for about 1 minute to make a smooth roux.
  3. Gradually add the milk, stirring continuously to prevent lumps (with Sylvia at the back of your mind at all times!). Keep stirring until the sauce thicken, which should usually happen after around 5–8 minutes.
  4. Take the sauce off the heat and stir in your salt, pepper and nutmeg if using. Add about 400g (14 oz) of the Cheddar, a handful at a time, stirring until melted and smooth. At this point, pop in all of your mozzarella, too. Keep around 100g (3½ oz) of Cheddar back for the top. You may also add more mozzarella to the topping, tossed in with the Cheddar, if you have more handy. 
  5. Combine the pasta and sauce by stirring the drained macaroni into the cheese sauce until thoroughly coated.
  6. Carefully tip your mixture into a large greased ovenproof dish. Scatter over the remaining cheese, combined or otherwise. 
  7. Bake for 20–25 minutes, until bubbling and golden on top.

Freezing Instructions for any leftover macaroni cheese 

  • Let the macaroni cheese cool completely.
  • Portion into freezer-safe dishes/containers.
  • Cover very well and freeze.
  • Leave off the final cheese topping until you're ready to bake it.
When you want to eat it, you can either:
  • Defrost overnight in the fridge, then add the cheese topping and bake at 190°C / 170°C fan for about 25–30 minutes, until piping hot throughout.
  • Or bake from frozen, covered with foil, at 180°C / 160°C fan for roughly 45–60 minutes, removing the foil towards the end and adding the cheese topping. Make sure the centre is thoroughly hot before serving.
One quick tip for additional servings: macaroni cheese can absorb quite a lot of sauce while freezing and reheating. If you're deliberately making some for the freezer, I'd keep those portions particularly saucy rather than letting the pasta soak up every bit of the cheese sauce. It will come out much nicer.

...and there you have it! A cyclical kitchen story, starting with my Grandma learning the art of a perfectly smooth white sauce at Catering college, to making macaroni cheese in her tiny Oxford flat as a young working woman, and coming to my own kitchen, where her starting methods have become part of my repertoire too. Always remember what she taught me: get the white sauce right to start with, and you need never fear a lump! 
I am gradually adding more of these personal recipes and family food memories to my Recipes page, with the intention of building up a proper collection of recipe cards over time. Some will be old family favourites, some will be inspired by recipes and cookbooks I have collected, and others will be dishes that have found a regular place at our own table.

No comments:

Post a Comment

The Art of Flower Pressing: An Old-Fashioned Pastime in Botanical Preservation & Memento-Making

Long after the flowers of a previous season’s bouquets and hedgerows have faded, flower pressing as a means of preservation offers a pleasin...